It may seem to readers that it's a long way from Finland to Hungary 1956 but I do actually have a way to connect the two.
Unlike Hungary, Finland was never occupied by Russia after the second world war and was never a member of the Warsaw Pact but Finland still had to be careful in its relationships with the rest of the world for a long time because a) Russia was still a threat that was just over the border and b) until 1956 Russia had a base (Porkala) within 50 kms of Helsinki.
Even so when I was in Helsinki in the Summer of 1968, working for the second year in succession as an AIESEC practicant, one of the things I remember even today was after the invasion of Czechoslovakia by Russian (and other Warsaw Pact countries') troops, there was a large demonstration in the centre of Helsinki (with its focal point if I remember correctly the same location - Market Square - that was used last Friday to celebrate the victory of the Finnish Heavy Rock band "Lordi" in the Eurovision Song Contest) with a large poster saying
1953 Berlin
1956 Budapest
1968 Prague
? Helsinki
It was a large but by and large non-aggressive demonstration but to avoid any major problems Finnish police (and perhaps other security forces) had set up a large cordon several kilometers around the location of the Russian Embassy. I know because I, like many others, tried to get to it via various routes all of which were blocked off a long way before you got anywhere near the Russian Embassy.
Anyway Budapest 1956 was on that banner and when I was recently in Budapest for the first time in 30 years I got hold of an early copy of a book about the Hungarian Revolution (which started in October 1956 and so the 50th Aniversary is coming up) written by a Brit (Bob Dent) who has lived in Budapest since the mid 1980's and who also speaks Hungarian and so could read documents not only in English but also in Hungarian while preparing the book.
The launch for the book is on the 31st of May so I'm jumping the gun by a couple of days but I've been reading the book (Budapest 1956 Locations of Drama - published by Europa) and it's a really interesting read for two main reasons.
The first is that the style is entertaining. There's a freshness about the book that perhaps comes out most in the fact that it's not dogmatic. It won't for instance say 4,000 attended a meeting but instead will say something like different sources give figures between 2000 and 8000 for the meeting. (Added later: This is actually a rather banal example. A better one is perhaps this one from a later chapter which mentions that some sources say that Pal Meletér (Defence Minister in the Nagy government) was planning a military coup and also that when taken prisoner at the Russian airbase on Csepel island outside Budapest (where he had gone for a second meeting to discuss Russian troop *withdrawal*) he had or had not made a statement and if made what this statement according to one source contained.)
The second is that it deals with the places where various events took place rather than dealing with events in a purely chronological order. Because of this it also is able to talk about the same place today (sometimes with recently taken photographs alongside the historic 1956 photographs) and whether the place or person is remembered in any way on or near the site. Only a person who has lived in Budapest throughout the changes that occured since 1989 would be able for instance to mention the discussions connected with the building of a new shopping centre on the same spot where a simple memorial to 1956 had been put up earlier (discussions that were solved by leaving the memorial in front of the shopping centre entrance and indeed adding a metal sculpture in the form of a flag to it to make it stand out).
So far I have two major problems.
One is that the book is so good that it's a pity that as things stand the English language edition (there is also a translated Hungarian edition) will only be available in Hungary as the Hungarian publisher seems to lack contacts outside Hungary because as far as I am aware this is the first book they have published in English. That's a great pity especially considering the potential market among people of Hungarian descent in the UK, Australia and especially the US.
Correction: The author has now written to me saying that somebody from the US had contacted him after reading this blog item (!). Although at the time I wrote it, the above paragraph was true, there is now a distributor for outside Hungary. He sent me the details which are below
Distributed outside Hungary by AK Distribution
PO Box 12766, Edinburgh EH8 9YE, UK
tel: (44-131) 555 5165; fax: (44-131) 555 5215
The second is that there is a map of Budapest in 1956 with places marked with numbers. Each location (where the 1956 events took place) is also in the body of the book marked with a number. *But* the numbers don't match. They do match for the first three locations/book sections which meant that it took me to book section 8 (still in Buda) to realise the map locations didn't match the book chapters (8 on the map was in Pest). Whereas in the page after the map there is a matching list of the locations used in the map, I can imagine that a lot of readers like me will be expecting the map numbers to match the book sections' numbers. As it is people will have to look at the location in the book section heading; look at the matching list (page after map) to see if the location is there; and then look at the map (if it is). All a bit messy and a great pity given the high quality of the prose section of the book.
Bringing this back to Finland again ... The book mentions at one point that Radio Free Europe (RFE) was at one point encouraging revolutionaries to hold out giving the (false) impression that help from the US was on its way. As part of this hold-out encouragement they gave instructions in how to make Molotov cocktails.
It was only recently that I read (elsewhere) that Molotov Cocktails had been invented by the Finns in the Winter War !
P.S. The other link between Finland and Hungary is of course the common membership in the Finno-Ugric language group (and the two largest single languages in the opposite ends of this group). Thus Hungarians are regarded as kinsfolk to a certain extent and for instance the Formula One Hungarian Grand Prix is regarded as Finland's home Grand Prix with always a substantial number of Finnish supporters there (much more than at any other Grand Prix).
Interestingly there is also a sort of fraternity between Hungarians and Poles because they once shared the same monarch(s?). So (going back to the book) one of the major early demonstrations that led to the Hungarian Revolution was a pro-Poland march (there is a photo in the book with two placards visible with words in Hungarian saying 'support the Poles" and a larger placard of the Polish Eagle) which took demonstrators to a statue in Buda of a Polish General who had supported the Hungarians in their 1848 Revolution against the Hapsburgs.
P.P.S. So far I've come across a couple of interesting before/after photographs in the book. The first one is a square near Moskva Tér that I mention earlier when talking about the monument in front of a modern shopping centre. There the 1956/present day comparison is a bit difficult to see because the photographs are taken from (it appears) somewhat different distances (I presume because the present-day photographer would have been standing in the middle of a busy road) and at a minutely different angle, so it's very difficult to see that the building on the left of the photo is the same in both cases (with that modern shopping centre replacing the buildings on the right). The other before/after photographs are of the Hungarian Radio building that was taken over by the rebels and (to my mind, amazingly) still IS used by Hungarian Radio. The modern photograph is taken from almost exactly (if not exactly - it's hard to tell) the same spot and it's an uncanny likeness with the same key balcony in place (where several short but important speeches took place) and with the only visible differences being the (typical) complete clean-up of the building (by 1970 when I lived in Budapest almost all the buildings' facades were covered with 25 years of grime); the replacement of the Magyár Rádio sign with a more modern and wider version; and the replacement of small overhead window panes at the back of the balcony with fewer larger ones.
P.P.P.S. I'm nearing the end (not there yet, I'm enjoying this to much to rush) so I had a look at the extensive list of book and article references (what, 10 pages ?) and the equally extensive index. (Note: when I was in Budapest I was told that most Hungarian books don't have indexes and that often if you want one you have to pay extra - not this one!) As I found the beginning of the book references, I couldn't help noticing the ending of the book, so I was curious and read the page or so before too. The ending was "why didn't Time have that on their cover?" and was a reference to a Russian soldier carrying an old woman to a house at the side of the road. The whole story was that there was a curfew but this old woman had ignored it and had spend all day distributing bread from a cart despite bullets flying around. Then towards evening she collapsed. A Russian soldier got off his tank and went over to the woman and picked her up. A Russian officer started shouting at him. The soldier replied briefly in a serious voice and continued carrying the old woman to the side of the road; knocked on a door; handed over the woman to the person who opened and then went back to his tank. Now my sympathies are well and truly with the revolutionary forces but I like the fact that the book is even-handed and gives praise where praise is due no matter on which side of the struggle the people were. (Not that the Russians get that much praise :) )
P.P.P.P.S I had to correct a date in the text above (the Polish General Bem helped the Hungarians in 1848 not 1948!) and so I can add a bit of trivia. The author of the book mentioned heavily in this text is Bob Dent. Before going to Budapest I'd bought the Blue Guide to Hungary by the same Bob Dent, so Amazon recently sent me an e-mail saying in effect that they are recommending a book on the Hungarian Revolution to people who had earlier bought the Blue Guide. So I thought they were recommending me this book by the same author. That would have been logical, but, no, they were offering me a book on the Hungarian Revolution by someone else. How odd. I bet it's not as good as this one!